ADVERTISEMENT

Great Steakhouses - a diversion thread

central17

SuperCane
Jan 31, 2005
7,645
10,350
113
Let's hear personal favorites; independents and chains; just great steaks and interesting places/scenery/people. Especially interested in any lessor known places that are not necessarily in the biggest cities.

Independents:
Peter Luger - Brooklyn, just amazing steak, simple old time steakhouse atmosphere. The Porterhouse should be on every steak lovers bucket list.

Nick & Sams - Dallas, great steaks and the talent can be amazing. It is a see and be scene place that you will likely notice someone famous. But the food absolutely carries its own weight.

Bern's - Tampa, Fabulous steaks of every possible cut to your weight and thickness choice. Impecable service. Plan on five hours. After the steak a tour of the spotless kitchen and wine cellar are on the way to the dessert room upstairs, where among many other things, ordering a Cognac from the 1800's is not out of the question.

Jimmy Kelly's - Nashville, a lessor known gem in an early 1900's house. Great steaks and great service. Still family owned, one of the owners is usually at the bar and visits each table. Simple menu and reasonable prices, the bone in Ribeye is as good as it gets.

Doe's - Greenville MS (the original). now this is off the beaten path an you will feel like you are in the 1950's. They have opened up several others in La.and Ar. You go in there not to impress anyone, but to get a delicious steak. I have been told that they have some kind of unique oven, don't know but it just works. The sides are decidedly simple southern classics.

Chains:
Smith & Wollensky - Everything is great, the sides are an event of their own. IMO, the best Truffled Mac & Cheese anywhere. Always a great experience and typically have an interesting clientele.

Ruth's Chris - I know alot of people knock them because they are a largely cookie cutter chain. But for me, when on business travel to mid size cities you are never going to go wrong if you don't know the best local places. And the steaks are just consistently good, the NY Strip and Cowboy Ribeye never disappoint.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: canam1965
The assessment of Nick & Sam's is spot on. Daughter is an SMU grad. Once she and my wife saw M/M Jerry Jones there as well as some Cowboy players.

Bern's is the total food experience, but order a small steak as their side portions are huge AND you must save room for The Dessert Room upstairs.
 
  • Like
Reactions: utatem and HJCane
Let's hear personal favorites; independents and chains; just great steaks and interesting places/scenery/people. Especially interested in any lessor known places that are not necessarily in the biggest cities.

Independents:
Peter Luger - Brooklyn, just amazing steak, simple old time steakhouse atmosphere. The Porterhouse should be on every steak lovers bucket list.

Nick & Sams - Dallas, great steaks and the talent can be amazing. It is a see and be scene place that you will likely notice someone famous. But the food absolutely carries its own weight.

Bern's - Tampa, Fabulous steaks of every possible cut to your weight and thickness choice. Impecable service. Plan on five hours. After the steak a tour of the spotless kitchen and wine cellar are on the way to the dessert room upstairs, where among many other things, ordering a Cognac from the 1800's is not out of the question.

Jimmy Kelly's - Nashville, a lessor known gem in an early 1900's house. Great steaks and great service. Still family owned, one of the owners is usually at the bar and visits each table. Simple menu and reasonable prices, the bone in Ribeye is as good as it gets.

Doe's - Greenville MS (the original). now this is off the beaten path an you will feel like you are in the 1950's. They have opened up several others in La.and Ar. You go in there not to impress anyone, but to get a delicious steak. I have been told that they have some kind of unique oven, don't know but it just works. The sides are decidedly simple southern classics.

Chains:
Smith & Wollensky - Everything is great, the sides are an event of their own. IMO, the best Truffled Mac & Cheese anywhere. Everything on the side menu is amazing. Always a great experience and typically have an interesting clientele.

Ruth's Chris - I know alot of people knock them because they are a largely cookie cutter chain. But for me, when on business travel to mid size cities you are never going to go wrong if you don't know the best local places. And the steaks are just consistently good, the NY Strip and Cowboy Ribeye never disappoint.
Berns is one of the best ever but I haven't been there for many years. SW Steakhouse in Vegas is great. Ruths Chris is hit or miss, but when they hit it right they're great.
 
Peter Luger has gone downhill. The waiters are assholes.
Been a while since I've been there. When I was there the waiters were not going to be your best friend, but were professional and efficient.
 
Smith & Wollensky is one of my favorites. Years ago, the one in Vegas had private rooms for bachelor parties where they allowed strippers and more to perform in the middle as you ate in a horseshoe boardroom format. Most ended up throwing fatty meat at the girls as some other acts were taking place. The good ole days!
 
  • Like
Reactions: thedonaldWYO
Let's hear personal favorites; independents and chains; just great steaks and interesting places/scenery/people. Especially interested in any lessor known places that are not necessarily in the biggest cities.

Independents:
Peter Luger - Brooklyn, just amazing steak, simple old time steakhouse atmosphere. The Porterhouse should be on every steak lovers bucket list.

Nick & Sams - Dallas, great steaks and the talent can be amazing. It is a see and be scene place that you will likely notice someone famous. But the food absolutely carries its own weight.

Bern's - Tampa, Fabulous steaks of every possible cut to your weight and thickness choice. Impecable service. Plan on five hours. After the steak a tour of the spotless kitchen and wine cellar are on the way to the dessert room upstairs, where among many other things, ordering a Cognac from the 1800's is not out of the question.

Jimmy Kelly's - Nashville, a lessor known gem in an early 1900's house. Great steaks and great service. Still family owned, one of the owners is usually at the bar and visits each table. Simple menu and reasonable prices, the bone in Ribeye is as good as it gets.

Doe's - Greenville MS (the original). now this is off the beaten path an you will feel like you are in the 1950's. They have opened up several others in La.and Ar. You go in there not to impress anyone, but to get a delicious steak. I have been told that they have some kind of unique oven, don't know but it just works. The sides are decidedly simple southern classics.

Chains:
Smith & Wollensky - Everything is great, the sides are an event of their own. IMO, the best Truffled Mac & Cheese anywhere. Always a great experience and typically have an interesting clientele.

Ruth's Chris - I know alot of people knock them because they are a largely cookie cutter chain. But for me, when on a business travel to mid size cities you are never going to go wrong if you don't know the best local places. And the steaks are just consistently good, the NY Strip and Cowboy Ribeye never disappoint.
Been to you first 3 all very good. For me the caviar bar at Nick and Sams was a fantastic surprise. I have a neighbor on the beach from Mississippi and he has told me about Doe's so I heard it is 1 of a kind fantastic.

As for Smith & Wollensky and Ruth Chris neither is a stand out to me but you won't get a bad steak at either. I have popped into the bar at Ruth Chris numerous times to throw down a steak in sizzling butter. Never wowed but not bad either.
 
The assessment of Nick & Sam's is spot on. Daughter is an SMU grad. Once she and my wife saw M/M Jerry Jones there as well as some Cowboy players.

Bern's is the total food experience, but order a small steak as their side portions are huge AND you must save room for The Dessert Room upstairs.
But only if they invite you up.
 
Let's hear personal favorites; independents and chains; just great steaks and interesting places/scenery/people. Especially interested in any lessor known places that are not necessarily in the biggest cities.

Independents:
Peter Luger - Brooklyn, just amazing steak, simple old time steakhouse atmosphere. The Porterhouse should be on every steak lovers bucket list.

Nick & Sams - Dallas, great steaks and the talent can be amazing. It is a see and be scene place that you will likely notice someone famous. But the food absolutely carries its own weight.

Bern's - Tampa, Fabulous steaks of every possible cut to your weight and thickness choice. Impecable service. Plan on five hours. After the steak a tour of the spotless kitchen and wine cellar are on the way to the dessert room upstairs, where among many other things, ordering a Cognac from the 1800's is not out of the question.

Jimmy Kelly's - Nashville, a lessor known gem in an early 1900's house. Great steaks and great service. Still family owned, one of the owners is usually at the bar and visits each table. Simple menu and reasonable prices, the bone in Ribeye is as good as it gets.

Doe's - Greenville MS (the original). now this is off the beaten path an you will feel like you are in the 1950's. They have opened up several others in La.and Ar. You go in there not to impress anyone, but to get a delicious steak. I have been told that they have some kind of unique oven, don't know but it just works. The sides are decidedly simple southern classics.

Chains:
Smith & Wollensky - Everything is great, the sides are an event of their own. IMO, the best Truffled Mac & Cheese anywhere. Always a great experience and typically have an interesting clientele.

Ruth's Chris - I know alot of people knock them because they are a largely cookie cutter chain. But for me, when on a business travel to mid size cities you are never going to go wrong if you don't know the best local places. And the steaks are just consistently good, the NY Strip and Cowboy Ribeye never disappoint.
I would add Old Homestead NYC to the independent list. Not as often spoken about but 125 years old and damn good.
 
  • Like
Reactions: central17
Let's hear personal favorites; independents and chains; just great steaks and interesting places/scenery/people. Especially interested in any lessor known places that are not necessarily in the biggest cities.

Independents:
Peter Luger - Brooklyn, just amazing steak, simple old time steakhouse atmosphere. The Porterhouse should be on every steak lovers bucket list.

Nick & Sams - Dallas, great steaks and the talent can be amazing. It is a see and be scene place that you will likely notice someone famous. But the food absolutely carries its own weight.

Bern's - Tampa, Fabulous steaks of every possible cut to your weight and thickness choice. Impecable service. Plan on five hours. After the steak a tour of the spotless kitchen and wine cellar are on the way to the dessert room upstairs, where among many other things, ordering a Cognac from the 1800's is not out of the question.

Jimmy Kelly's - Nashville, a lessor known gem in an early 1900's house. Great steaks and great service. Still family owned, one of the owners is usually at the bar and visits each table. Simple menu and reasonable prices, the bone in Ribeye is as good as it gets.

Doe's - Greenville MS (the original). now this is off the beaten path an you will feel like you are in the 1950's. They have opened up several others in La.and Ar. You go in there not to impress anyone, but to get a delicious steak. I have been told that they have some kind of unique oven, don't know but it just works. The sides are decidedly simple southern classics.

Chains:
Smith & Wollensky - Everything is great, the sides are an event of their own. IMO, the best Truffled Mac & Cheese anywhere. Always a great experience and typically have an interesting clientele.

Ruth's Chris - I know alot of people knock them because they are a largely cookie cutter chain. But for me, when on a business travel to mid size cities you are never going to go wrong if you don't know the best local places. And the steaks are just consistently good, the NY Strip and Cowboy Ribeye never disappoint.
They are all over rated ..!!!! Rather go to my personal butcher and grill it myself...
 
They are all over rated ..!!!! Rather go to my personal butcher and grill it myself...
I'm sure you are a great cook but there is something about going to a great steakhouse for dinner and cocktails.
 
But only if they invite you up.

You don't always have to go to a pure steakhouse for an outstanding steak. 6882 of Canesport has a restaurant .. The Vineyard Wine Co. .. in Lake Mary, Florida. Excellent eclectic menu .. and the Filet Mignon I had there was outstanding .. easily as good as what I have had at Morton's.
Thank you! That is what is great to hear. Great places for steak that we might not know about.
 
Can't believe I forgot to mention this place before. Hunters Pub in Hamilton GA. It's just outside of Columbus, GA. The owner supplies all of the High-End steakhouses in ATL (Mortons, Bones, etc..). Very simple, diner-like atmosphere. They serve fried lobster tails too that are incredible! They open at 5 and have a good wait from 6:00 on. SENSATIONAL PLACE! Peanut butter pie for dessert, wear your fat pants! If you're ever in South GA in that area, this place is a must!
 
You don't always have to go to a pure steakhouse for an outstanding steak. 6882 of Canesport has a restaurant .. The Vineyard Wine Co. .. in Lake Mary, Florida. Excellent eclectic menu .. and the Filet Mignon I had there was outstanding .. easily as good as what I have had at Morton's.
Very true. There are Italian restaurants that make great steaks and chops.
 
Let's hear personal favorites; independents and chains; just great steaks and interesting places/scenery/people. Especially interested in any lessor known places that are not necessarily in the biggest cities.

Independents:
Peter Luger - Brooklyn, just amazing steak, simple old time steakhouse atmosphere. The Porterhouse should be on every steak lovers bucket list.

Nick & Sams - Dallas, great steaks and the talent can be amazing. It is a see and be scene place that you will likely notice someone famous. But the food absolutely carries its own weight.

Bern's - Tampa, Fabulous steaks of every possible cut to your weight and thickness choice. Impecable service. Plan on five hours. After the steak a tour of the spotless kitchen and wine cellar are on the way to the dessert room upstairs, where among many other things, ordering a Cognac from the 1800's is not out of the question.

Jimmy Kelly's - Nashville, a lessor known gem in an early 1900's house. Great steaks and great service. Still family owned, one of the owners is usually at the bar and visits each table. Simple menu and reasonable prices, the bone in Ribeye is as good as it gets.

Doe's - Greenville MS (the original). now this is off the beaten path an you will feel like you are in the 1950's. They have opened up several others in La.and Ar. You go in there not to impress anyone, but to get a delicious steak. I have been told that they have some kind of unique oven, don't know but it just works. The sides are decidedly simple southern classics.

Chains:
Smith & Wollensky - Everything is great, the sides are an event of their own. IMO, the best Truffled Mac & Cheese anywhere. Always a great experience and typically have an interesting clientele.

Ruth's Chris - I know alot of people knock them because they are a largely cookie cutter chain. But for me, when on a business travel to mid size cities you are never going to go wrong if you don't know the best local places. And the steaks are just consistently good, the NY Strip and Cowboy Ribeye never disappoint.

Central's the man. Peter Luger's in Brooklyn...when I went there, another lifetime ago, Curley's son (yes that Curley, woo, woo, woo) was a waiter there. However, when I was at the U, best steaks were Black Caesar's Forge and La Pena. Been there, too late now?
 
Christine Lee’s ( Hallandale @ Gulf Stream ), Chinese restaurants with perhaps the best filet in town IMO
 
Central's the man. Peter Luger's in Brooklyn...when I went there, another lifetime ago, Curley's son (yes that Curley, woo, woo, woo) was a waiter there. However, when I was at the U, best steaks were Black Caesar's Forge and La Pena. Been there, too late now?
Curley didn’t have a son two daughters, Janie and Marilyn. Somebody played you.
 
You don't always have to go to a pure steakhouse for an outstanding steak. 6882 of Canesport has a restaurant .. The Vineyard Wine Co. .. in Lake Mary, Florida. Excellent eclectic menu .. and the Filet Mignon I had there was outstanding .. easily as good as what I have had at Morton's.
I haven’t been to 6882’s restaurant. But, I know him as a wine expert with great taste. So, I’m trusting that his cuisine is similarly high level, delicious and fun.

Get on over to Lake Mary!
 
  • Like
Reactions: 289fia
I'm sure you are a great cook but there is something about going to a great steakhouse for dinner and cocktails.
Truth is I did this for many many years closing business deals just rather cook myself or bring in an up and coming chef to cook a meal for you and friends..
 
I'm sure you are a great cook but there is something about going to a great steakhouse for dinner and cocktails.
Agree. It’s about relaxing, ambiance and being catered to. I can cook really great steaks and slow smoke ribs and butts, but going out occasionally is great too.
 
  • Like
Reactions: HJCane
Sparks Steakhouse in N.Y.C. Paul Castellano says hi...and bye.
Berns in Tampa is a good one.
 
  • Like
Reactions: jpboca
You know you’re old when your cardiologist tells you not to eat steak at steakhouses! Thank God Mastro’s (Tillman Fertita’s high end steakhouse chain) also serves outstanding sushi and fabulous cocktails. I love going to Mastro’s in Vegas and Newport Beach, CA.
 
Last edited:
Bern's is great, biggest wine list in the world, Peter Luger's Brooklyn was great in the 80's and Spark's Steak House in NYC, I was there 1 week to the day before Big Paul Castellano got hit by Gotti. Now THAT would have been an epic night. Another great one I liked is The Palm Too...NYC great place, and of course Morton's Chicago (the original) in the chain category, had dinner there 2 months ago, it was www:flavor.com ...lol JMO
 
Last edited:
Bern's is great, biggest wine list in the world, Peter Luger's Brooklyn was great in the 80's and Spark's Steak House in NYC, I was there 1 week to the day before Big Paul Castellano got hit by Gotti. Now THAT would have been an epic night. Another great one I liked is The Palm Too...NYC great place, and of course Morton's Chicago (the original) in the chain category, had dinner there 2 months ago, it was www:flavor.com ...lol JMO
The Palm was great in its day!
 
Bern's is great, biggest wine list in the world, Peter Luger's Brooklyn was great in the 80's and Spark's Steak House in NYC, I was there 1 week to the day before Big Paul Castellano got hit by Gotti. Now THAT would have been an epic night. Another great one I liked is The Palm Too...NYC great place, and of course Morton's Chicago (the original) in the chain category, had dinner there 2 months ago, it was www:flavor.com ...lol JMO
Gibsons in Chicago is real good. Their Tomahawk cut is the largest steak that I have ever seen. Their N.Y. Strips are incredible. BTW, the bar is filled with hookers. It took exactly 3 minutes to find that out! Lol.
 
  • Like
Reactions: jpboca
Gibsons in Chicago is real good. Their Tomahawk cut is the largest steak that I have ever seen. Their N.Y. Strips are incredible. BTW, the bar is filled with hookers. It took exactly 3 minutes to find that out! Lol.
Is there a nice hotel nearby? Asking for a friend.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Allied2651
Is there a nice hotel nearby? Asking for a friend.
There's

Thompson Chicago, 21 E Bellevue Pl, Chicago, IL 60611 right across the street ...should be fine..bon appetite,,!​

4-star hotel OR

Waldorf Astoria Chicago​

5-star hotel
11 E Walton St, Chicago, IL 60611
about 2 blocks away
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Allied2651
Gibsons in Chicago is real good. Their Tomahawk cut is the largest steak that I have ever seen. Their N.Y. Strips are incredible. BTW, the bar is filled with hookers. It took exactly 3 minutes to find that out! Lol.
Didn't love Gibsons. Not bad just over rated. Chicago Cut was great but was the loudest restaurant I ever ate at. So much so, I would never return
 
You don't always have to go to a pure steakhouse for an outstanding steak. 6882 of Canesport has a restaurant .. The Vineyard Wine Co. .. in Lake Mary, Florida. Excellent eclectic menu .. and the Filet Mignon I had there was outstanding .. easily as good as what I have had at Morton's.
I haven’t been to 6882’s restaurant. But, I know him as a wine expert with great taste. So, I’m trusting that his cuisine is similarly high level, delicious and fun.

Get on over to Lake Mary!
Thank you, I appreciate it guys.

if I had to throw my two cents in with central fl alone because they’re just too many out there to even think about.... man there’s a lot of them. In no oder, central fl...

normands at the ritz before they closed (inconsistent but when they were on, it was as good as any place I’ve ever been and they’re supposedly reopening some where else)

bull and bear at alfond has a limited menu and it’s touristy, Not going to lie but what they do, they do well.

oceans prime use to be the shit but now it’s over priced shit. Really disappointed in this place in every category. Done giving them chances which is a shame too because at one time they were as good as anyone.

christinis is Italian but their steaks are as good as you can ask for and the atmosphere is just really cool and the service, wine list, derek the accordion player, chris the owner working the room, etc... just a bad ass place fir a special occasion. It is expensive but I think they deliver.

Eddie V’s food is second to none. I hate the atmosphere though. It’s just loud, crowded (not in a good way like gibsons or joe’s), hookers, posers, mediocre service. It’s a shame too because their food is really good.

Victori and alberts at grand Floridian is the best restaurant in Orlando and one of the best in the world. Everything they do is the best of the best. So freaking expensive and stuffy though that it kinda get’s taken out of any category. It is the best though. Very hard to justify their price on any restaurant any where but it is worth going to every ten or twenty years IF you’re really into restaurants. These places just don’t exist anymore.

Emeralds is also clearly touristy but when they first opened my family got the private opus x room and I had easily one of the best filets I’ve ever had. It’s been a long time since then so I can’t help but wonder if they really were that good on that night or if that’s just how they do things. Never really hear about them though so probably just went on their best night when they were still trying to make a name around town.

then there is my number one....Christners on lee road formerly known as del friscos. Old, traditional classy, not going to lie kinda worn and out dated in some areas but their somm is as good as they come, their wine list is one of few in central fl that rivals ours and everything on their menu which is extensive is awesome. Where can you still find a beef wellington let alone one that’s done really good? Love their sides, love their seafood. Their cheese board has fresh wisconsin cheese curds (that’s cool and hard to find in orlando). Their piano player in the tux in the lounge, the wine lockers, the top shelf spirits behind the bar... it’s just a really cool place.

oh ya, then there’s my place but I’m clearly biased.

i think then you kind of have your next tear of places like ruth’s, capital, palm, mortins, flemmings, etc which i would have to say are all kind of in the same catagory. Maybe best to least. Mortins, ruths lake mary, palm, capitol idrive, flemmings
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: central17
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest posts

ADVERTISEMENT